If you’ve been searching for the perfect country escape —
one that combines modern comfort with wide-open spaces — 5440 Eminence Pike in Shelbyville, Kentucky is the home you’ve been waiting for. This stunning 31-acre estate features a custom-built 4-bedroom brick home, an in-ground pool, horse facilities, and breathtaking views — all just a short drive to Louisville and Lexington.
This is your chance to enjoy true Kentucky living — whether you’re relocating from California, New York, Texas, or anywhere else looking for a slower pace and more space to thrive.
Property Overview
Price: $1,250,000
Address: 5440 Eminence Pike, Shelbyville, KY 40065
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 3
Square Feet: 3,931
Lot Size: 31 Acres
Year Built: 2001
Property Listing
Interior Features
Step inside this beautiful home and experience the perfect balance of comfort and sophistication.
Spacious Open Layout: Ideal for both entertaining and daily living
Custom Kitchen: High-end finishes, modern appliances, and ample cabinetry
Luxurious Bathrooms: Thoughtfully designed with upscale fixtures
Generous Bedrooms: Four large bedrooms for family or guests
Attached 2.5-Car Garage: Convenient parking and storage
Outdoor Living
Outside, the property is a true rural retreat designed for relaxation and recreation.
In-Ground Pool & Hot Tub: Your private backyard oasis
Expansive Patio Space: Perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings under the stars
Sweeping Views: Enjoy serene Kentucky countryside every day
Equestrian & Farm Features
For horse lovers, hobby farmers, or anyone looking for a functional farm, this property delivers:
Large Barn & Workshop: Ample space for equipment and projects
Horse Barn: 6 stalls, tack room, and fenced paddocks
31 Usable Acres: Ideal for horses, livestock, or crops
Location & Lifestyle
5440 Eminence Pike is just minutes from downtown Shelbyville, offering shopping, dining, and local charm. The property’s location also provides an easy commute to Louisville (40 minutes) or Lexington (1 hour), giving you access to city amenities while enjoying the peace and quiet of rural living.
✨ 31 Acres of Kentucky Beauty ✨
Why Buyers Love Shelbyville, Kentucky
Shelbyville combines the peace and space of the country with the convenience and charm of small-town living. This Kentucky city is a highly attractive option for families and professionals relocating from large, high-cost states like California, New York, and Texas. Here’s what makes it stand out:
Strong Sense of Community & Historic Charm
With a population of about 17,800 (as of mid-2023), Shelbyville is large enough to offer amenities and activity, but small enough to retain its warm, neighborly feel. Census.gov Kentucky Demographics City of Shelbyville
Our downtown is beautifully preserved, filled with local shops, historic architecture, and an arts scene that includes festivals, equestrian events, and community theatre. It’s the kind of place where you recognize faces and feel connected. HollyMelody City of Shelbyville
Affordable Cost of Living Compared to Big Cities
Shelbyville offers real value. The cost of living is lower than the U.S. average in several key categories. Housing prices tend to be significantly more affordable than in many markets in CA, NY, or TX. Local Observer Daily Kentucky Demographics
For example, median home values are well below national norms, and general expenses — groceries, utilities, property taxes — tend to be more reasonable. This means more house, more land, and more breathing room for your budget. Local Observer Daily Kentucky Demographics
Young, Growing, and Diverse
The median age in Shelbyville is about 36.8 years, suggesting a vibrant mix of families, young professionals, and people making mid-career moves. Kentucky Demographics
The population is also becoming increasingly diverse: Shelbyville is about ~65% White, ~9-10% Black, and ~20% Hispanic / Latino. This diversity brings cultural richness — food, festivals, community life — that many new residents appreciate. Census Dots Kentucky Demographics
Outdoor Recreation, Equestrian Tradition & Cultural Attractions
For those who love the outdoors or horses, Shelbyville is a dream. It’s known as a center of the Saddlebred horse world. Local riding trails, barns, and horse farms are a defining part of the landscape and culture. HollyMelody Southern Living
Nature lovers will enjoy Guist Creek Lake for boating, fishing, and camping. The Shelby Trails Park & Red Fern Riding Center provide trails and riding arenas for both casual and serious equestrian activity. The Tourist Checklist
Add to that charming local food, boutique shopping, distilleries like Jeptha Creed and Bulleit, and seasonal community festivals, and there’s always something to do — without the crowds of bigger cities. HollyMelody Southern Living
Convenient Location
Shelbyville gives you the best of both worlds when it comes to access. You’re not isolated — Louisville and Lexington are within reach, giving you employment opportunities, airports, universities, healthcare, and city-amenities when you want them. But you come back home to land, peace, and a roughly 31-acre estate like 5440 Eminence Pike feels like a true escape.
Schedule a Private Tour
This property is move-in ready and waiting for its next owner to create lasting memories.
📅 Schedule your private showing today and experience everything 5440 Eminence Pike has to offer. Contact us for more details or to arrange a tour — virtual or in person!